By Garret DeReus, January 7, 2025

Louisiana’s Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs) show concerning patterns of inadequate oversight. Recent data reveals thousands of abuse and neglect reports go uninvestigated, while facilities face minimal financial penalties despite receiving substantial Medicaid funding per resident. These systemic issues raise serious concerns about resident safety in Louisiana’s 501 ICFs serving over 4,000 vulnerable individuals.

What Are Intermediate Care Facilities?

ICFs provide round-the-clock residential care for individuals with developmental disabilities. These facilities assist residents with daily activities like eating, hygiene, and medication management while ensuring access to essential services including speech therapy, physical therapy, and regular medical care. In fiscal year 2023, Louisiana’s 501 ICFs served 4,122 residents, such that ICFs received, on average, approximately $97,889 in annual Medicaid funding per resident.

Licensing and Regulatory Requirements

As explained in our previous article on ICF licensing requirements, the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals maintains oversight of ICFs through initial background checks, compliance surveys, and various written policy requirements, including detailed admission criteria.

Beyond these basic operational requirements, LDH has significant regulatory responsibilities related to facility monitoring and incident response. The department maintains two primary oversight mechanisms: a complaint system and a mandatory incident reporting system.

Through its complaint system, LDH accepts and reviews reports of concerns from residents, families, staff members, and other individuals regarding ICF operations and resident care. These complaints trigger a review process that may lead to formal investigations when warranted.

Additionally, Louisiana regulations mandate that ICFs self-report certain incidents through what are known as Facility Reported Incidents (FRIs). Using a web-based critical incident reporting system, facilities must notify LDH of any events involving:

• Abuse (whether by staff or other residents)
• Neglect
• Death
• Exploitation
• Misappropriation of resident property
• Injuries of unknown origin
• Any other serious threats to resident health, safety, or well-being

The purpose of these regulatory requirements is to create multiple channels for identifying and addressing potential harm to residents. However, as we’ll explore in the following sections, significant questions exist about the effectiveness of these oversight mechanisms in practice.

The Troubling Reality of ICF Oversight

Data from 2019-2023 reveals a deeply concerning pattern of inadequate oversight and enforcement in Louisiana’s Intermediate Care Facilities. During this period, the Louisiana Department of Health received 718 complaints about ICF facilities, yet only investigated 441 of these reports. Even more alarming is that 58.5% of the investigated complaints – 258 cases – were found to be valid, suggesting widespread problems across these facilities.

Perhaps most disturbing is the handling of self-reported incidents. ICF facilities themselves reported 4,698 incidents related to abuse and neglect during this period, yet LDH initiated investigations into only 32 of these cases. This means that less than 1% of self-reported abuse and neglect incidents received any investigation by the LDH. This massive oversight gap suggests thousands of potential cases of abuse and neglect have gone uninvestigated, leaving vulnerable residents at risk.

The financial penalties imposed on these facilities also raise serious concerns about accountability. The total fines levied during this period amounted to $450,250 over five years, averaging approximately $21.85 per resident per year. To put this in perspective, facilities receive an average of $97,889 in annual Medicaid funding per resident. This means the average annual fine amounts to just 0.02% of a facility’s per-resident revenue. Such minimal financial consequences are unlikely to motivate meaningful changes in facility operations or encourage investment in better staffing, training, or safety measures.

This stark disparity between funding and fines effectively creates a system where the financial risk of non-compliance is negligible compared to the cost of proper care. When facilities face such limited consequences for violations, they may calculate that paying occasional fines is less expensive than maintaining proper staffing levels or implementing comprehensive safety protocols. This economic reality, combined with insufficient regulatory oversight, creates an environment where the basic safety and dignity of vulnerable residents may be compromised in favor of financial considerations.

Documented Cases of Negligence in Louisiana ICFs

The substantiated complaints against Louisiana ICFs reveal deeply troubling patterns of inadequate care, negligent supervision, and failures to properly investigate abuse. While the following examples represent only a small sample of documented cases, they illustrate systemic issues that put vulnerable residents at risk.

In one particularly disturbing case, facility staff failed to administer prescribed morphine to a resident prior to wound care treatment, subjecting the individual to unnecessary pain during a medical procedure. This basic failure to follow physician’s orders demonstrates how even fundamental aspects of patient care can be neglected.

Another case highlights the dangerous consequences of inadequate staffing and supervision. A resident, left unsupervised, put their arm through a glass window and required emergency hospital treatment. In a similar incident reflecting insufficient monitoring, a resident fell and suffered a head laceration requiring hospital care after being allowed to use the bathroom alone, despite requiring one-on-one supervision.

Perhaps most concerning are the failures in abuse investigation protocols. Documentation shows that when abuse or neglect was alleged, some facilities failed to conduct thorough investigations by not interviewing all potential staff members and witnesses who might have had relevant information. This breakdown in the investigative process not only leaves specific incidents unresolved but also creates an environment where abuse or neglect might go undetected and unaddressed.

These cases must be viewed within the broader context of facility oversight. Louisiana regulations require ICFs to report any incidents involving abuse, neglect, death, or serious threats to residents’ health and safety. These Facility Reported Incidents (FRIs) include allegations of abuse by both staff and other residents, exploitation, misappropriation of residents’ property, and injuries of unknown origin. The fact that facilities self-reported 4,698 such incidents over a five-year period, yet only 32 were investigated by state authorities, suggests these documented cases may represent only the tip of the iceberg in terms of actual resident harm and neglect.

***

If you have a loved one in an ICF facility who has experienced abuse, neglect, or substandard care, contact us for a confidential consultation to discuss your situation.